Google staff push to let schools keep Search without AI
Google says AI is built into Search, so a school that bans AI loses the search tool too.
The answer
Google workers petition for schools to disable AI in Search, keeping Search.
Google's education business faces internal and political pressure over how AI is bundled into Search. More than 500 Google workers and contractors signed a petition titled "Let Students Search", started by the Alphabet Workers Union. It asks the company to let K-12 schools turn off AI features in Search without losing the search tool itself. Gizmodo's report on the petition published on 19 November; one outlet cites more than 540 signatures. Union president Parul Koul, a Google software engineer, and Rob Rose, a union member on Google's Education team, spoke about it.
The bundling is the core of the dispute. Google says AI is built into Search, so a school that bans AI cannot switch it off without losing Search, and students at such schools would see a message that the feature is unavailable. Chris Phillips, Google's VP for Education, told the New York Times: "Search and AI are deeply integrated."
Customers are pushing back. New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani accused Google of using its monopoly power to force AI into public schools. The New York Times reports that Los Angeles and Chicago districts are considering switching to alternative search engines. On 9 November, Senator Ed Markey wrote to Google asking whether schools could keep Search with AI switched off.
Google says it plans to disable AI features for students by default. A planned initiative, expected early next year, would let schools turn Search, Gemini and Gemini Notebook on or off individually. Google has not committed to a fully AI-free version of Search. Bloomberg has also reported the petition, although this desk has not reviewed that coverage.
The Insider view
The pressure lands on Google's schools channel, where its position rests on Search being a single product. The early-next-year switches are the concession to watch. If they ship with individual controls for Search, the bundling argument weakens and the district talks in Los Angeles and Chicago lose urgency. If they do not, those districts' consideration of rival engines becomes the real test of how much schools will pay for Google's AI-integrated Search.
Google is trying to keep one product and offer a default-off promise at the same time. Until it commits to an AI-free Search, that balance is unresolved, and districts and regulators will judge it by what schools can actually switch off.
Sources
- Google Employees Want Schools to Use Search Without AIGizmodo · 19 November 2026
Free · no sign-up · no spam
Never miss a InsidersFeed story
Add our free feed to any news reader and every new story lands there the moment we publish it.